My Little Pony – $900

Steve D’Aguanno, Bonnie Zacherle, and Charles Muenchinger were the people behind My Little Pony, distributed by Hasbro in the ’80s. These toy ponies featured colorful, luscious manes and tails and vibrant plastic bodies. This line was one of the most enduring as it spawned a movie.

Although most of the ponies were just cute and attractive, there were certain designs that now cost more than their original price. For instance, the “Rapunzel” pony, which is inspired by the fairytale of the same title, is very rare and may sell for $900 if in mint condition.